Flowers v. Mississippi
Case Overview
Curtis Flowers was tried six times for the same quadruple murder in Winona, Mississippi, with the same prosecutor using peremptory strikes to remove virtually every Black prospective juror across the trials. The Supreme Court reversed 7-2 in 2019, finding that the history of race-based juror exclusion across all six trials was directly relevant to assessing whether the sixth trial violated Batson v. Kentucky. The decision is notable for permitting cross-trial analysis of a prosecutor's pattern of discriminatory strikes.
The Conclusion
**The Supreme Court reversed 7-2, holding that a prosecutor's pattern of race-based juror strikes across multiple trials is relevant to assessing Batson violations.** The decision permitted cross-trial analysis to evaluate whether systematic exclusion of Black jurors demonstrated intentional discrimination, rather than evaluating each trial in isolation.
No circuit court data for this case.
Case Analysis
Overview
Curtis Flowers was tried six times for the same quadruple murder in Winona, Mississippi, with the same prosecutor using peremptory strikes to remove virtually every Black prospective juror across the trials. The Supreme Court reversed 7-2 in 2019, finding that the history of race-based juror exclusion across all six trials was directly relevant to assessing whether the sixth trial violated Batson v. Kentucky. The decision is notable for permitting cross-trial analysis of a prosecutor's pattern of discriminatory strikes.
Conclusion
**The Supreme Court reversed 7-2, holding that a prosecutor's pattern of race-based juror strikes across multiple trials is relevant to assessing Batson violations.** The decision permitted cross-trial analysis to evaluate whether systematic exclusion of Black jurors demonstrated intentional discrimination, rather than evaluating each trial in isolation.
Notes
588 U.S. 284 (2019). Applied Batson v. Kentucky (1986). Permitted cross-trial analysis of prosecutorial pattern of peremptory strikes.
Flag an issue
This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support