African Communities Together v. Lyons
Case Overview
2 non-profit organizations sued the Department of Homeland Security over the the detention of immigrants following their immigration hearings in court.
BrynoDC Coverage 1 video
The Application
Plaintiffs argue that detaining immigrants after court appearances deters access to hearings and effects seizures without adequate legal process. DHS asserts statutory authority to enforce immigration law regardless of location, but courts have increasingly recognized that courthouse enforcement raises distinct constitutional concerns.
The Conclusion
The case remains active in the Southern District of New York before Judge P. Kevin Castel as of the August 2025 filing, with resolution pending on whether the courthouse arrest policy exceeds constitutional and statutory bounds.
Case Analysis
Overview
2 non-profit organizations sued the Department of Homeland Security over the the detention of immigrants following their immigration hearings in court.
Issue
Whether the Department of Homeland Security's policy of detaining immigrants immediately following their immigration court hearings violates constitutional protections against unreasonable seizures and due process rights.
Rule
Sanctuary courthouse policies and the Fourth Amendment prohibit certain immigration enforcement activities within courthouse premises. Courts scrutinize whether enforcement policies comply with constitutional protections and statutory authorization, particularly when detention occurs immediately after judicial proceedings.
Analysis
Plaintiffs argue that detaining immigrants after court appearances deters access to hearings and effects seizures without adequate legal process. DHS asserts statutory authority to enforce immigration law regardless of location, but courts have increasingly recognized that courthouse enforcement raises distinct constitutional concerns.
Conclusion
The case remains active in the Southern District of New York before Judge P. Kevin Castel as of the August 2025 filing, with resolution pending on whether the courthouse arrest policy exceeds constitutional and statutory bounds.
Flag an issue
This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support