American Federation of State, County and Municipal v. SSA
Case Overview
The government appealed Judge Hollander's preliminary injunction which prevents the Social Security Administration from granting DOGE affiliated employees access to personally identifiable information at SSA.
The Application
Judge Hollander found that AFSCME likely could establish a legal violation in SSA's access grant and that blocking access would prevent irreparable injury to union members and statutory compliance. The balance of equities and public interest in proper government procedure supported maintaining the injunction pending resolution of the underlying administrative law claims.
The Conclusion
The Fourth Circuit decided the appeal regarding the preliminary injunction status as of April 18, 2025, addressing the scope of DOGE employees' access to SSA personal data pending final adjudication.
Case Analysis
Issue
Whether the Social Security Administration may grant DOGE-affiliated employees access to personally identifiable information, and whether a preliminary injunction preventing such access should be maintained pending appellate review.
Rule
A preliminary injunction may be upheld if the moving party demonstrates likelihood of success on the merits, likelihood of irreparable harm absent the injunction, that the balance of equities favors maintaining it, and that it does not disserve the public interest. An appellate court reviews for abuse of discretion.
Analysis
Judge Hollander found that AFSCME likely could establish a legal violation in SSA's access grant and that blocking access would prevent irreparable injury to union members and statutory compliance. The balance of equities and public interest in proper government procedure supported maintaining the injunction pending resolution of the underlying administrative law claims.
Conclusion
The Fourth Circuit decided the appeal regarding the preliminary injunction status as of April 18, 2025, addressing the scope of DOGE employees' access to SSA personal data pending final adjudication.
Overview
The government appealed Judge Hollander's preliminary injunction which prevents the Social Security Administration from granting DOGE affiliated employees access to personally identifiable information at SSA.
Flag an issue
This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support