City of New York v. President Trump
Case Overview
New York City sued the Trump administration over the removal of $80.5 million from a bank account of the City of New York that had been deposited by FEMA to assist with shelter and services for immigrants.
BrynoDC Coverage 1 video
The Application
The Trump administration removed $80.5 million in FEMA-deposited funds from NYC's account designated for shelter and immigrant services. NYC challenges the removal as an unauthorized Executive rescission of federally appropriated funds.
The Conclusion
The case is active before Judge Jennifer H. Rearden in the Southern District of New York. The outcome depends on whether the court finds statutory or constitutional authority for the Executive's removal of the appropriated funds.
Case Analysis
Overview
New York City sued the Trump administration over the removal of $80.5 million from a bank account of the City of New York that had been deposited by FEMA to assist with shelter and services for immigrants.
Issue
Whether the President has constitutional and statutory authority to rescind and remove federal FEMA funds that had been appropriated and deposited in New York City's account for immigrant shelter services.
Rule
The Antideficiency Act and separation-of-powers doctrine limit the Executive's power to rescind appropriated funds absent explicit statutory authority. Under the Youngstown Steel framework, presidential action must fall within constitutional and statutory bounds, with Congress retaining control over appropriated funds.
Analysis
The Trump administration removed $80.5 million in FEMA-deposited funds from NYC's account designated for shelter and immigrant services. NYC challenges the removal as an unauthorized Executive rescission of federally appropriated funds.
Conclusion
The case is active before Judge Jennifer H. Rearden in the Southern District of New York. The outcome depends on whether the court finds statutory or constitutional authority for the Executive's removal of the appropriated funds.
Flag an issue
This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support