Doctors for America v. Office of Personnel Management
Case Overview
Doctors for America, represented by Public Citizen, sued the Office of Personnel Management, the CDC, the FDA, and the HHS for removing webpages and datasets used by public health researchers. The suit alleges that the removal of these pages violates the Administrative Procedures Act.
Legal Issues
BrynoDC Coverage 5 videos
The Application
The agencies removed publicly accessible health datasets and webpages that public health researchers relied upon, allegedly without complying with APA procedural requirements or providing reasoned explanation for the removal.
The Conclusion
The court found in favor of Doctors for America, determining that the removals violated the APA; the case is in compliance monitoring, suggesting the court imposed ongoing requirements for agency adherence to APA procedures regarding data access.
No circuit court data for this case.
No Supreme Court data for this case.
Case Analysis
Issue
Whether the removal of public health webpages and datasets by the CDC, FDA, HHS, and OPM violated the Administrative Procedures Act.
Rule
The APA requires federal agencies to follow proper notice-and-comment procedures before taking final agency action affecting the public, and prohibits agency actions that are arbitrary and capricious or unsupported by the administrative record.
Analysis
The agencies removed publicly accessible health datasets and webpages that public health researchers relied upon, allegedly without complying with APA procedural requirements or providing reasoned explanation for the removal.
Conclusion
The court found in favor of Doctors for America, determining that the removals violated the APA; the case is in compliance monitoring, suggesting the court imposed ongoing requirements for agency adherence to APA procedures regarding data access.
Notes
D.D.C. Consolidated from multiple extraction rows.
Overview
Doctors for America, represented by Public Citizen, sued the Office of Personnel Management, the CDC, the FDA, and the HHS for removing webpages and datasets used by public health researchers. The suit alleges that the removal of these pages violates the Administrative Procedures Act.
Flag an issue
This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support