Patsy Widakuswara v. Kari Lake (VOA appeal, D.C. Cir. 2026)
Case Overview
The government appealed Judge Lamberth's order granting partial summary judgement which required the reinstatement of USAGM employees and vacated the cessation of U.S. Agency for Global Media broadcasting.
The Application
The district court found no genuine dispute that the government failed to comply with statutory requirements governing USAGM operations, granting summary judgment that the cessation of broadcasting was improper and that affected employees must be reinstated.
The Conclusion
Judge Lamberth's order requiring reinstatement of USAGM employees and vacating the cessation of broadcasting is currently on appeal in the DC Circuit; the lower court's judgment remains in effect pending appellate review.
Case Analysis
Overview
The government appealed Judge Lamberth's preliminary injunction preventing the government from dismantling the Voice of America.
Overview
The government appealed Judge Lamberth's order granting partial summary judgement which required the reinstatement of USAGM employees and vacated the cessation of U.S. Agency for Global Media broadcasting.
Issue
Whether the government has statutory or constitutional authority to dismantle the Voice of America and whether a preliminary injunction against such dismantling was properly issued.
Rule
A preliminary injunction requires: (1) likely success on the merits; (2) irreparable harm without the injunction; (3) favorable balance of equities; and (4) public interest alignment. Executive authority to restructure or eliminate independent agencies is constrained by applicable statutes and constitutional principles.
Analysis
The district court found sufficient grounds for the preliminary injunction, indicating likely success on a statutory or constitutional theory protecting VOA's independence, combined with irreparable harm to journalistic independence and the public interest in maintaining an independent federal broadcaster.
Conclusion
The preliminary injunction preventing VOA's dismantling remains in effect; the government has appealed to the DC Circuit, challenging the legal basis for the lower court's order.
Notes
CourtListener 404. Docket may have been removed or ID is incorrect
Flag an issue
This tracker is maintained by BrynoDC and is free because readers fund it. Support